Admittedly, I'm not much of a joiner when it comes to blogfests (though I love making the rounds and watching everybody else do them) but this one was too fun to pass up. Madeleine from Scribble and Edit wants to know which novels made good movies, and I have some definite opinions on this one.
And I even managed to turn this into a top 10 list:
10. Bridget Jones's Diary by Helen Fielding
I liked the book, but I loved the movie. Perfectly cast. (And you can follow Bridget on Twitter at @bridgetjoneshf.)
9. The Bone Collector by Jeffery Deaver
It's no secret that I'm a rabid fan of Deaver, and that I adore his series character, forensics expert Lincoln Rhyme. But the movie's great, too! I finally got to ask Deaver at ThrillerFest what he thought of the movie casting (because in the book, Lincoln's white), and he said, "I know a lot of people think it's racist to ask what I think of Denzel Washington playing Lincoln, but it isn't. It's a perfectly valid question. As to what I think – hey, it's Denzel. Anything to get him in a movie."
8. The Bourne Identity by Robert Ludlum
I thought the movie was much better paced than the book, which I found a little slow and a tad over-written. And it also helps that I'm a fan of Matt Damon.
7. The Green Mile by Stephen King
This was originally a serial novel, where chunks of the book were released each month, and I didn't find the story to be as seamless as it should have been. But the movie smoothed out all the lumps and bumps, and who doesn't like Tom Hanks? (And we won't talk about the other, 51-year-old actor who recently married a 16-year-old. Ewww.)
6. Princess Bride by William Goldman
Again, I thought the movie was better paced than the book. But the book is just as funny, and goes a little deeper character-wise.
5. Interview With a Vampire by Anne Rice
This book is my favorite of the Vampire Chronicles, and I thought the movie stayed true to the voice and most of the story. Rice was happy with adaptation, and for good reason. Plus, Brad Pitt as Louis? Yes.
4. The Silence of the Lambs by Thomas Harris
I read the book before I saw the movie, and will say that Sir Anthony Hopkins really made Hannibal Lecter come alive for me. The movie really captures the tension and freakiness of the dual serial killer plotline.
3. Stand By Me (The Body) by Stephen King
A nice little story from King's compilation, Different Seasons, made into a classic movie. I've read the story a few times, but I've seen the movie about a dozen times.
2. Fight Club by Chuck Palahniuk
I can't decide which I like better, the movie or the book. The writing in the book is as close to perfect as a writer could ever hope for, but the movie is just so visceral. And Brad Pitt as Tyler Durden? Yes.
1. Shawshank Redemption (Rita Hayworth and the Shawshank Redemption) by Stephen King
Another nice little story from Different Seasons that turned into an incredible movie. I doubt I have to explain why the movie was so amazing – you've likely seen it, and already know why.
Bonus: Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone
Book and movie are equally delightful, and this first Harry Potter story will always be my favorite of the series.
What are your favorite books-turned-into-movies? Do you agree or disagree with any of my picks?
* * *












Couldn't agree with this list more if I tried! Great selections.
ReplyDeleteGreat list. There's a few there though that I never finished reading like Bridget Jones and Bourne. I started them but couldn't get into the style of writing. Shawshank is an amazing film, not read the book though. :O)
ReplyDeleteLove this list! Great picks - especially PRINCESS BRIDE! :D Buttercup!!!!
ReplyDeleteLOVED THIS LIST!!! I'd say the only one I disagreed with was The Princess Bride and that's because I LOVED THE BOOK!!!! I read it and then watched the movie and was so disappointed. I still am today. Is that sad?
ReplyDeletePS - I'm such a blonde! I looked to the write and saw a post titled: Dead People & Candlelight. I was like "I'M GOING THERE NEXT"... then I realized I'm the one that wrote it. Hey, at least I know how to market to myself!
Great list!
ReplyDeleteI'm not a big fan of movies based on books, but these are definitely some of the best.
for interview, I saw the movie first and didn't really like it, was still not sure after reading the first book, but it is apparent that Tom Cruise had read Lestat before taking on the role, because he nailed Lestat.
ReplyDeleteI love all those movies. I haven't read them all as novels, though. Totally agree that the Bourne movies are WAY better than the books. Great list.
ReplyDeleteGreat List! I loved the book the Shining and I loved the movie even though their are a lot of differences between the two.
ReplyDeleteYou win so many points for Fight Club. And now I want to go watch it.
ReplyDeleteAh you've got some goodies here. Silence of the Lambs and the Bone Collector are great films. I didn't know they had been books first, either.
ReplyDeleteFreakin' awesome list and you are so right about the Green Mile, Shawshank, Stand by Me, and of course Harry Potter (first will always be the fav). But I totally forgot about Interview with a Vampire!!! Love me some Anne Rice and that movie was perfectly cast.
ReplyDeleteThe others were all great movies but didn't read the books. Isn't this fun???? I'm such a dork.
I love Harry Potter and the Sorcerer's Stone--it's different from the other stories in that Harry's just learning about magic. :)
ReplyDeleteHell yes! This is a great list! I usually think books trump movies, but you've pointed out several that I had forgotten!
ReplyDeleteMy favorite book-into-movie is Stephen King's 'The Dead Zone'. I read the book first, saw the movie (and instantly crushed on Christopher Walken...yes, I like the weird-looking ones), then read the book again. I've seen the movie many times and still love it.
ReplyDeleteAs for your picks, I haven't read the books but I loved Bridget Jones's Diary (Colin Firth is YUMMY!), The Princess Bride, Silence of the Lambs (is it sick that I crushed on Anthony Hopkins...in the mask?), and Stand By Me.
Hi,
ReplyDeleteSimply love Ludlum and A. Rice books. Hate Stephen K novels and never read or movie watched HP: the latter always reminds me of brown sauce! ;)
best
F
lol.... I love it. I'm with you... anything witth Brad in it is A-OK for me. ;)
ReplyDeleteI agree with Anthony Hopkins as Lecter. One of my fave characters of all times, and Hopkins did an amazing job with him. Man, Fight Club is one of my fave movies and I didn't even know it was a book. I must check that out.
I agree with you on your comment on my blog about Count of Monte Cristo.... I enjoyed the book and love the story, but I prefer the most recent film version also. Same with Dracula, Stardust, and Jaws.
I haven't read any of these books, but I've seen all the movies (except Harry Potter) and liked them. Although recently I did get berated by my daughters and sons-in-law for stating that I rewatched Fight Club and was disappointed and didn't like it as well I had thought I did. I may have been influenced by the fact that my wife hated the movie and begrudgingly sat through it til the end which made my viewing uncomfortable. It was good, but not as good as I had thought it was.
ReplyDeleteLee
Tossing It Out
I have the feeling that Hunger Games will be my favorite! But then, I still have to wait to know for sure. Gosh, I hate waiting.
ReplyDeleteAnd yes! Loved your picks! :D
All the ones that I've seen on this list are AMAZING. Good taste :)
ReplyDeleteFrom your newest follower
Oh, and CREEP sounds amazing. I'm off to add it to be TBR list on Goodreads...
ReplyDeleteThat is a fabulous list. I've seen most of the films you mention but not read so many of the books. I need to add some more to my to read shelf.
ReplyDeleteI always meant to get round to reading The Princess Bride, maybe I will one day...
ReplyDeleteOMG, I forgot Bridget Jones! I added it to my list after seeing it here. hehe. I loved both the book and the movie.
ReplyDeleteI haven't read or seen many of yours, but I definitely agree with you about The Princess Bride! Thanks for joining in the blogfest.
ReplyDeleteIf you get a chance, check out a fellow writer's zombie story and help me make him wear an embarrassing shirt next year! It's the ultimate grudge match between social media and the zombies. Details are here:
http://kelworthfiles.wordpress.com/2011/07/19/prove-the-zombies-wrong-social-platforms-can-build-readership/
I found the earlier Harry Potter films a bit disappointing. But as a loyal fan of the books I watched every single film! Nice top ten list :-)
ReplyDeleteThis is a great list! I loved pretty much all of your choices. And it inspired me to make a list of my very own! :-)
ReplyDeleteCheck it out:
http://dilking2002.blogspot.com/2011/08/top-ten-book-movies.html
I've seen every one of these movies, and a few of them several dozen times. But I'm embarrassed to admit that I've only read one of the books. (Two if you include Harry Potter.) I really need to read more...
ReplyDelete